Skull_pumpkin_small
Reputation: 1610

What does bruising liquor (I've usually heard the term applied to gin) mean and why is this bad?

Asker's Favorite

  • Paulclarke_small
    Reputation: 34

    I think the whole "bruising" notion is a bunch of hooey -- really, if you go one-on-one with a bottle of gin, who's more likely to come out bruised?

    Anyway, it usually comes up in the shaking vs. stirring debate when it comes to martinis. Here's the basic rule of thumb, which James Bond confused for all of us: if a drink's ingredients are all booze (spirits, liqueurs, aromatic wines like vermouth, etc.), then stir the drink; if you have fruit juice or dairy products or the like, shake it.

    The rationale is that stirring the drink introduces less air into the cocktail, so the result is smoother in the mouth and more visually appealing in the glass (and if you doubt how much difference shaking vs. stirring can make, keep an eye out for one of those shaken-until-it-has-a-head-on-it Manhattans that are so prevalent). With juice and other ingredients, you'll chill it faster by shaking it, and with these drinks you might even want some bubbles along for the ride.

    Can you shake a martini? If you like it that way, go for it. It'll be bubbly and kinda cloudy at first, but bruised? Nah.

    Share this answer with a friend:

2 Other Answers

  • Sugarskull_jmc_small
    Reputation: 453

    "Bruising" is when water,usually from ice chipping off in a shaker, is introduced to a cocktail.
    It's usually only brought up by proponents of stirring or muddling vs. shaking.
    People bitch about it most with gin because it tends to make the gin cloudy and veteran alcoholics claim it compromises the flavor (I'm not big on gin-flavor to begin with, so I can't tell the difference). If it's a carbonated drink like champagne in a bellini or something it can also make it go flat.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • N610441624_6271_small
    Reputation: 93

    So... the whole thing about shaking gin has less to do the process of shaking and more to do with the materials. Many bartenders claim that gin in particular reacts with metal - thereby changing the flavor. Most shakers are made from stainless steel, silver or an alloy of some sort. Stirring gin in a glass minimizes contact with a metal and, therefore, preserves the flavor.

    Share this answer with a friend: