800px-groundhog-standing2_small
Reputation: 360

Advice on how to make the most delicious grilled cheese sandwich on the planet?

I am throwing a grilled cheese party! Looking for smart techniques for grilling techniques, equipment to use, recommendations on bread, innovative ingredients (charcuterie, Mama Lil's, shrooms, whatever).

Answer this question or share it with a smart friend:

Avatar_default
Type your answer here…

Asker's Favorite

  • Tumblr_leinmgsqic1qg3q4go1_500_small
    Reputation: 70

    One key is, of course, don't be stingy. I butter the bread inside and out. Use sharp or extra sharp cheddar (Beecher's is delish). Use a hot cast iron pan, don't butter the pan, just the bread. Start with cool, excellent quality, fresh butter. I love a solid white bread, or Essential Rosemary Diamante (I don't really love any of their other breads, but this one is salty and rosemary-y, and gets crispy! Cheese should be sliced medium thick, not too thin or thick.

    The next key for me is - start the pan on medium hot to brown the sandwich, then turn it down to medium low, and put a lid on it - but not for long! You don't want any steam to soften the bread at all, just keep the heat in for a moment to melt the cheese faster. Let it sit for a moment to resolidify on a wooden board (so it doesn't get soggy on a plate) when done, then cut in half diagonally.

    Serve with Guiness or hard French cider and a good apple or pear. It should be a sunny fall day, and the leaves are turning. You just finished a hard Saturday afternoon's work in the garden. OMG.

    Share this answer with a friend:

7 Other Answers

  • Sheri_tattoo_small_small
    Reputation: 96

    The super frico is a super tasty take on grilled cheese, in fact I just posted a bit about them on the shop's FB site: http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Calf-Kid/56599653023

    In general, here are a few rules of thumb to follow for great grilled cheese:

    1. always shred your cheese, this helps it melt quickly and evenly, you'll wind up with a lot less burnt bread.

    2. use a heavy pan, like a cast iron skillet and make sure it's heated up thoroughly

    3. butter the bread rather than melting it in the pan, this will also prevent the bread from burning

    As far as cheese goes, classics like a good aged Gruyere or cheddar are always delicious, but it's also a lot of fun to throw in some unexpected tidbits in there like an aged goat, a little ooey gooey washed rind, or a little blue.
    Have fun and enjoy!

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Nose_small
    Reputation: 1276
    Moderator

    I like Texas toast because it is delicious and durable, so you can pile ingredients on without losing flavor or compromising structural integrity. Plus, it makes it easier to maintain a good bread-to-filling ratio when using lots of add-ins. My dream grilled cheese would have buttery, extra crunchy bread (with a maintained give to it when bitten), gruyere cheese, prosciutto, and a tart cherry compote (I like Woodring Orchard's which you can get at Pike Place Market), perhaps with a slice of brie or camembert on it, like Cirrus from Mt. Townsend. I would toast the Texas toast a little first, then butter its outsides (and insides, too, most likely. Hello, Paula Deen). Then, I'd apply gruyere on each side, with the toppings in the middle, and the cherry compote applied thinly so that the cheese can stick together around the ham. It would taste similar to a Monte Cristo, but much, much better.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Michaelnatkin_small

    Have you ever noticed how the most delicious part of a grilled cheese is the crispy bits where the cheese has leaked out and fried to a crisp? Then you, my friend, need the SuperFrico. Rick James soundtrack optional.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Hayes_valley__76__small

    For a local take on Grilled Cheese: Try Essential Baking Company's Rosemary Bread cut into 3/4" thick slices...layer with thin slices of Mt. Townsend Creamery's Trailhead Tomme. If you like heat drizzle with any of the Mama Lil's peppers oil (just the oil for a hint of spice)...butter the bread (try Rose Valley unsalted butter)...heat up your favorite cast iron skillet and grill that baby until golden brown and oozing.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Barexam220_small

    For inspiration, you should go directly to Grim's and try the leek/asiago grilled cheese. Grim's is brand new on Capitol Hill and goofily overdecorated in the Quinn's/Smith/Oddfellows reclaimed-crap mode (all newly installed in the old Grey Gallery space, which makes it extra weird), but the sandwiches are inexpensive and this particular grilled cheese knocked my socks off last Thursday. Knocked my mouth's socks off? Anyway, it was really good. Seems like you'd soften up chopped leeks over medium-low heat in lots of butter, then spread a layer of them inside the grilled cheese... mmmmm. WANT NOW. Hi!

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Horse_ass2_small
    Reputation: 751

    Do not forget mustard. It makes cheap cheese taste great and great cheese taste even better.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Icon_small
    Reputation: 1627

    On a recommendation, I recently made a grilled cheese with rye bread, sharp cheddar cheese, and grilled onions. It was fab.

    Share this answer with a friend: