Chrysanthemum_small
Reputation: 49

How many exemptions should I claim on my W4?

I started a new job recently and entered 2 exemptions on the W4 form based on the worksheet but am now thinking I should change it. I've heard a lot of conflicting advice and am having trouble finding the answer online but if I want larger paychecks, is it best to increase or decrease the number of exemptions?

Answer this question or share it with a smart friend:

Avatar_default
Type your answer here…

3 Answers

  • Spaceship_small
    Reputation: 1812

    An increase in the number of excemptions from witholding leaves more money in your paycheck... but it also means less money is being held back to over your taxes when it comes time to pay them.

    A decrease in the number of exemptions means the govt will hang onto more money so that that pool will be available to offset your taxbill when you file.

    At least, that's how I understand it.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Dinolock_small
    Reputation: 976

    I've been claiming 2 on salary for years and always break even or owe a tiny bit (<$100) each tax season. I'm firmly in the "screw giving the IRS an interest free loan by overpaying" camp.

    You know withholdings are totally optional as long as you don't have a history of tax problems. If you really want, you can ask your employer to not withhold anything and do your own taxes at the end of the year.

    If you take this seriously, be prepared to write a check for 15-20% or so of your total yearly income before April! If you don't, you will owe more than you can pay, get penalties, be put on a payment plan with the IRS that could turn into a garnish of your paycheck in a worse case scenario, and you'll probably have paycheck withholdings forced onto you for being bad at taxes.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • 6521205-0-large_small
    Reputation: 1345

    OMC is right. Increasing exemptions increases your take home pay by decreasing the amount that is withheld to offset your tax bill.

    Typically you take 1 exemption for yourself.
    +1 if you have a spouse filing jointly.
    +1 (or more) if you have a mortgage.
    etc. based on any other tax deductible items you will have.

    If you have been getting big refunds in the past then your exemptions should be higher than they were before. If your refunds have been minimal then you has the correct exemptions and should leave it as it was. The worksheets tend to err on the side of getting you to over withhold in my experience.

    Share this answer with a friend: