2959482589_d59a69c6e4_small
Reputation: 281

Where in Seattle can I buy safe (silica-free) play sand for sandboxes?

Apparently, the stuff they sell at Home Depot (and even Toys R Us) that is supposedly safe play sand, actually contains silica. Like most things, silica exposure is known to cause cancer. Online retailers charge way too much for shipping it. (Sadly, sand is not eligible for Amazon Prime.) A company called Sandtastik distributes safe sand but the closest retailer, according to their website, is Bellevue. I'll go there if I have to, but I'd rather not.

Answer this question or share it with a smart friend:

Avatar_default
Type your answer here…

Asker's Favorite

  • Avatar_default
    Reputation: 21

    We just went through this same thing and found something "safe" enough to buy for our toddler. Fred Meyer (in Ballard) carries Play Sand from Mutual Materials, a local company. So we called them. They were VERY helpful and looked up the MSDS on their products. Theirs is a natural product - river bed sand. Also he said the silica of respirable size is less than .051% by weight. I forget what he said was the acceptable threshold, but this is way low for silica exposure. He also told us that if we wanted to go with a larger grain sand, since the concern is really with the dustiness of the sand, their Design Mix Paver Joining Sand is the least dusty of all their products. This is different than their paver joining sand sold at the big box stores, so you have to buy it from a Mutual Materials location - Bellevue, Redmond, Kent, Mukilteo, etc. This product is also washed, etc, so it's a fine substitute. Deciding to err on the safer side of things, we drove out to get a bag (80 lbs for around $6) of the Design Mix Paver Joining Sand. We haven't opened it up yet to see the exact size of the bits. I'm sure this sand won't adhere as well for making sand castles, etc. but I'm pretty sure my son just wants to dump it all over right now anyway, so that's not my concern. But I do feel the Mutual Materials Play Sand we saw at Fred Meyer is a fine option and if it does seem dusty at all, I read elsewhere where people suggested just keeping it a tad damp. Hope that helps!

    Share this answer with a friend:

1 Other Answer

  • Avatar_default
    Reputation: 831

    How much of the stuff do you need? I'd think that if you're filling up a whole sandbox with it, buying it in bulk might be a lot cheaper than buying individuals bags retail. Shipping should be cheaper because it will come on a pallet on a delivery truck instead of UPS.For example, that sandtastik company takes bulk orders: http://www.sandtastik.com/sandtastik-sand/sandtastik-white-play-sand/128-sandtastik-safe-sand-bulk

    Even one of those little turtle-shaped sandboxes will take 150 lbs of sand, so you could probably easily justify a 200 lb order.

    However, if I were you I'd just call around to local rock and and sand dealers. The issue isn't with silica in sand (most sand is virtually all silica!), but with extremely fine-grained silica crystals that can be inhaled. In natural sand, this isn't a problem because the same geologic processes that sorted the sand into sand-sized particles washed away all the smaller stuff. It becomes an issue with manufactured sand, where they take larger quartz-containing rocks (quartz is the same thing as silica) and crush them up into sand-sized grains, leaving finer stuff in there too.

    But given where we live, I'll bet that practically all the local rock yards and landscape places that sell play-type sand are selling natural sand. Locally-harvested natural bulk sand should be perfectly safe and much cheaper to boot (to say nothing of the environmental costs of hauling sand all the way across the country from Florida where true silica-free carbonate sand comes from).

    Now, if you'll indulge me in a slight tangent, I think the safe-sand thing is a bit of a scam. The whole thing got started because in California silica-based sand is required to contain a Prop. 65 warning saying that it contains material known by the State of California to cause cancer. But the risk this refers to is only applies to workers who are frequently exposed to dust produced by sandblasting. There is absolutely zero evidence to suggest there is any risk posed by just playing in the stuff, even if it is the manufactured kind that could contain silica dust. But since the play sand is basically the same stuff as the sandblasting sand, it also has to carry the warning. The kid's play sand with the cancer warning on it elicits images of Irwin Mainway* and so someone came up with the bright idea of selling non-silica based sand that doesn't have to carry the warning. After all, what decent parent would choose the cancer sand? It's a variation of this principle: http://xkcd.com/641/

    *http://snltranscripts.jt.org/76/76jconsumerprobe.phtml

    Share this answer with a friend: