Dscn0421_small
Reputation: 1195

Which e-reader do I want?

I'm finally starting to get on board with the whole e-reader trend after resisting for quite a while. I love real hard copy books, and that's not going to change, but the siren song of convenience is starting to become overwhelmingly tempting. I read a lot- multiple hours every day, and I already know that I will be comfortable reading books on a device because I've been using my laptop for about a quarter of my reading for the last year. Looking at comparisons of various models, however, I'm a little overwhelmed by all the details. Which one do I want?

I want the device to be fairly versatile as far as environment goes- I do a lot of reading in the dark with a sleeping SO next to me, so a lighted backscreen sounds appealing (which is how it works when I read on my computer), but the info I'm reading seems to suggest that e-readers with lit screens are going to be difficult if not impossible to read in daylight, which would definitely be a problem. Anybody have recommendations for lights specifically designed to be used with these devices? A lot of those on offer just seem like the usual clip-on "reading lights" that cast a too-small circle of dim light and constantly fall off of books. I'd want that was sturdy, reliable, and preferably semi-permanently attachable to the device itself.

As far as access to books goes, I know that Kindle has only recently started supporting library books, but when I checked out the fact sheet on Amazon it looked like I'd have to pay (.15 per MB?) to have the books "delivered" to my device. That seems like bs. Am I misreading? The majority of the books I'll be reading on this device will likely be library books or public domain books, so this is pretty important to me- I don't have a lot of disposable income for books but I do read a ton. Making notes and highlighting and such is not important to me- I'm not the kind of person who writes in books normally and I'll mostly be reading fiction. I'm currently only familiar with PDF and ePub formats for ebooks, as I do all of my current ebook reading in Adobe Digital Editions. That makes the Nook feel more appealing because it supports these formats, but I don't know if there's really a difference as far as the reading experience goes.

I'm a bit confused about the wifi vs. 3G features- obviously, if I get a wifi only version, I'll only be able to download books when I'm connected to the internet via a wifi network and otherwise I'll be able to download books from anywhere, but... the Kindle's facts sheet looks like it says that even if I have a 3G device I won't be able to use it for any web browsing other than book downloading and wikipedia unless I'm connected to a wifi network. Is that so? (The only attraction here is to look up the occasional bus schedule- I don't want a device that I can use regularly for web surfing, and I would be okay with it not being able to do this at all, but being able to use it for this purpose is the only real reason I can think of for me to pay more for 3G).

It looks like the Nook has better battery life than the Kindle (60 hours versus 30 hours without wifi turned on), but there's no way either one of them is going to last me a month at at time between charges, so I'm not that terribly concerned about it.

So...what do you guys think? Am I overlooking significant factors? I'm pretty much vacillating between a Kindle and a Nook, but that's probably because I don't have patience to wade through info about other brands. If I go with the Kindle, do I want the ad-supported version, or should I cough up the extra cash to avoid the ads? Money is certainly a factor- I don't want to be paying $200 when I could be getting all the functions I need for $80. Speak to me, oh experienced e-reading Q'landers!

p.s. I did read the other questions pertaining to this, but several new readers have come out in the time since those questions were asked and I wanted to get advice specifically tailored to my preferences.

Answer this question or share it with a smart friend:

Avatar_default
Type your answer here…

Asker's Favorite

  • Min-wage_small
    Reputation: 1421

    I bought last year's kindle as my boyfriend's birthday present, and he loves it. I definitely agree with David about getting a reader with an e-ink screen - I also use the kindle sometimes, and reading text on the e-ink screen is so much easier on the eyes than a backlit screen. You don't get color but it's worth it.

    Because you want to read in the dark, look at getting a nice case with a built-in light. They're expensive - you'll probably spend $50 easy on that. If I want to read when my boyfriend's falling asleep, he puts on a sleep mask. I think you should ask your SO if this is an option - I didn't like the light from the little reading lamp, and sleep masks aren't that expensive.

    In your case, I think you should look for the device that best supports the ebook formats you are already using. I think the Nook Simple Touch (e-ink) is your best bet - it's the same screen as the Kindle, it supports ePub, and it's only $99 ($79 in-store this Friday!). You don't need 3G, and the Kindle web browser sucks - it's really slow, and you can't access any non-Amazon sites on a 3G only connection.

    I would say close 2nd is the Sony Reader, but do go and compare as David suggests. I like the design and feel of the Nook and Kindle better. 3rd choice is the cheaper Kindle - the ads are only on the screensaver and the index page, and if you do change your mind you can pay Amazon the difference to get the ads taken off.

    There isn't any delivery charge to get library books on the Kindle, btw - I think the charge you saw was for transferring personal documents, which you don't want to do. However I have to say that I didn't see all that many ebooks available from the library that interest me.

    I totally understand why you are having such a hard time choosing - the reason I went with the Kindle last year is because my boyfriend already had an Amazon Prime account and bought a lot of books from Amazon. I hate supporting devices that are obvious portals for one business, and Kindle is the epitome of this - if you like Amazon, you'll love the Kindle. But if you're not planning on joining Amazon Prime, there's nothing that sets the Kindle above the Nook.

    Share this answer with a friend:

4 Other Answers

  • David_library_small

    I don't want to endorse, but I would go ahead and at least make it a three-way race, including Kindle, Nook and the Sony Reader, which has a good new slim wifi model. I'd advise that while the B&N is still located in University Village, to go on down and look over the Nook, and then go just down the way to the Sony store and look at their readers - it is nice to get a feel for them. If you can bring a friend's Kindle along, so much the better.

    Although it may seem counterintuitive from your computer/tablet/phone reading experience, I'd advise you really don't want to be using a backlit screen, but the latest and best eInk screens. Yes - you do need a light for this - my own pocket-sized Sony reader is accessorized with a protective cover (which I need anyway) that has a built in light in the spine, and it works fine - otherwise you pretty much read it like you'd read a paper book, in appropriate lighting.

    eBook access through libraries is changing and evolving, so anything we say here about the relative merits of devices re: library content is liable to expire before your device does. That said, I'd be remiss if I failed to point out that many public librarians have their issues with how things have started off w/ the Kindle.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Avatar_default
    Reputation: 239

    There was a review of the new Nook in the Seattle Times yesterday or today (11/25/11 or 11/2611). Both the review, and the reader comments (quite passionate Nook users), may help you discern more about the benefits and differences between the new Kindle and Nook devices.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Iconeke-794_small
    Reputation: 145

    I have a Kobo touch, which is super-basic, but I love it.

    It's wifi-enabled, though I haven't used that part yet, words with Adobe digital editions or calibre (has it's own software as well, but I haven't used it), can take library books, is very lightweight, and pretty cheap (especially as they're just come out with their own tablet-esque ereader as well)

    Also, like the sony ereader, you can use it for epubs from any store, so it's pretty versatile. I have bought epubs, gutenberg epubs, and library books on there, and it runs pretty much perfectly.

    Share this answer with a friend:
  • Rex_racer_small
    Reputation: 690

    keep holding out until the iPad becomes an all in one phone/tv remote/iBook reader/personal italian confidential secretary.

    Share this answer with a friend: