Ask Seattle A Question
Insurance
20110127-rk8ynawup62s75g982phb44p4i

Car, house, life, flood, earthquake etc. Cover your risk. (ask about health insurance in the health category)

Answers
  • If a person's falling body lands on/damages your car, what are the insurance and legal implications?
    Yosemite_ariel_small

    #1 - Your Car - The person plummeting to their death and crashing into your car would be considered a missile (in the general sense of the word). Therefore, initially, if you had Comprehensive coverage on the car, your insurance company would cover the damage to the car, minus your Comp deductible.

    #2 - Suicidal Jumper's Injuries - If you have Personal Injury Protection coverage on your vehicle, your policy will actually pay for that jumper's medical expenses, if he/she lives, or funeral expenses, should they die (up to the limits stated in your actual policy, for medical, usually $10K and funeral $5K, and whether or not the coverage would cover the jumper varies by state).

    #3 - Intent - The intent of the jumper would have to have been to land on your car, specifically, for this to matter, and since that information would be nearly impossible to obtain, this is an interesting, but ultimately moot question.

    #4 - Victim was pushed - Again, unless the person pushing the other was aiming for your car, this doesn't matter. The damage to your car would still be considered to be caused by negligence (probably...again, varies by state). In the case of the pushed person, your claim is against the pusher. If they jump, against them directly.

    #5 - No 1st Party Coverage on your car - wait 'til they die or recover enough to leave the hospital before you present them with a claim (assuming there are no statutes of limitations that would toll by doing so). Nobody likes an asshole; not even lawyers and judges.

  • Should a simple broken arm cost so much?
    Finn3goof_small

    Swedish is the worst when it comes to that shit. I've stopped going to their emergency room (not that I'm a terribly regular visitor). I have a few particuarly worrisome and painful chronic conditions that I know how to treat. But they won't listen and kept testing me and giving me ultrasounds.

    I now go to Virginia Mason or, rarely, Carolyn Downes (sp?). Wam bam thank you ma'm and I'm outta there. It's really that different.

    I understand (having nothing but anecdotes to back it up with) that the larger insurance companies really don't dig Swedish at all, but I'm not sure that's a dig on Swedish.

    and don't use a fucking circ saw on your daughter for christ's sake. My last cast I took off my sliding a piece of steel down the cast to protect my leg and then running the dremel over that it until I could crack it open. I probably didn't need the steel but had never done it before.

  • Do you have a personal jewelry appraisal reference??
    Mototour_small

    I go to Alan Chappron, G.G., N.G.J.A.. I've used him twice so he fits my tried and true gem/jewelry appraiser criterion.
    His company is Gemological Consulting Services, Suite 325, 500 Union Street Seattle, Washington 98101

    Phone: 206-624-3798.

    I don't have an artisan reference. I'll be interested to read the responses of others for this category.

Questions
Recent Comments
  • Comment on Malcolmxy's answer…
    Yosemite_ariel_small

    What kind of dickweed? The kind that works as a subrogation (collection) specialist for an insurance company. The one part I forgot to mention is that while the PIP insurance would initially cover medical expenses or funeral costs, the insurance company would then immediately try to recover their money from the jumper or the jumper's estate.

    I did insurance claims many moons ago, and I saw some weird shit, but nothing quite like this (probably because people who jump use the Aurora Bridge or The Narrows, and the likelihood of hitting a car from either of those is pretty slim, or near impossible in the case of The Narrows). It's all about reading and understanding contracts...you can give me pretty much any scenario and unless there's been recent court decisions that nullify a portion of the contract or add to it, I can pretty much tell you what would happen.

    It's not the best skill to have at parties, but it's a skill, I suppose.

    Glad to help (it was actually fun to think through all that crap again.)

  • Comment on totheteeth's answer…
    Img_5852_small

    Oh, my question was not inspired by current events, just a pedestrian was acting weird and pointing at the top of a building. We were driving and couldn't see the top of the building, so someone suggested there might be a jumper. eek.

    However, I then learned that a friend had witnessed an incident where a guy jumped onto I-5. http://www.komonews.com/news/local/Man-dies-after-jumping-onto-I-5-in-downtown-Seattle-147504795.html I've assumed that that's what totheteeth saw, and I'm very sorry for it. *hugs*

  • Comment on totheteeth's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    What are you talking about? Is this a common problem in the Pacific Northwest, or did something just happen that the rest of us are unaware of?

  • Comment on Malcolmxy's answer…
    Img_5852_small

    Thanks for the information. Hoping noone ever has to use it. When arguing with my pals, I kept basically saying "just use your comprehensive coverage and move on." I mean, what dickweed is going to show up at the hospital or graveyard with an invoice, right? But my pal's point was that your property was damaged by another person, and you have legal recourse. And I was sure that there had to be official answers to this question, as I'm sure it's happened before. Again, thanks for the info.

  • Comment on totheteeth's answer…
    Img_5852_small

    Oh man, hugs and healing vibes. Yeah, no good.

  • Comment on Tracy M's answer…
    05-01-06_1814_small

    Cool, thank you.

  • Comment on Luckier's answer…
    Squirrelhat_small

    It's not all out of pocket, but it's certainly waaay more than we can afford. I am keeping my fingers crossed that we can renegotiate something more affordable. Thanks for the anecdotal evidence that this can work. :)

  • Comment on Kip Waddle's answer…
    Squirrelhat_small

    Yes, I believe I may have to chalk this up to a very expensive lesson.

  • Comment on O my captain's answer…
    Squirrelhat_small

    I promise I was kidding. I would NEVER take a circular saw to my daughter's arm.. my own, maybe. A dremel is not the worst idea, tho'.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Squirrelhat_small

    Thank you; it did not occur to me that different emergency rooms might be less expensive. Good idea for the future.

    I was joking about home removal, but now that you mention the dremel, we have lots of dremels around here....

  • Comment on RacerX's answer…
    Icon_small

    That's a good question. I'll definitely avoid answering any questions relating to my address or finances, but that's sound advice no matter who's calling.

  • Comment on RacerX's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    How certain are you that this strange call is REALLY from your insurance company? I'm mean, what's to stop me from calling and claiming that I'm from your auto insurance company and that I have a few blanks to fill in to continue your policy. How would you know that it wasn't a phishing expedition?

  • Comment on RacerX's answer…
    Icon_small

    It's not necessarily paranoia; I screen all my calls if I don't recognize the number.

    It's not so much that I don't want them knowing my medical information, it's that: 1. I don't want to waste 20 minutes of my precious personal time; 2. I don't want to give my medical information over the phone to some boob who has exactly zero medical training.

    I'm mainly just slightly worried that they'll penalize me somehow for not complying, but then if they were that desperate to get this information, they'd leave a message and ask me to get back to them.

  • Comment on Fnarf's answer…
    Gold-head_small

    We'll see who's still around in an hour or so.

  • Comment on Fnarf's answer…
    249925_104388806317611_100002394765073_42124_5109547_n_small

    you fucken ass hole

  • Comment on Russ Campbell, NWEBS's answer…
    Avatar_default

    I did file a complaint with the WA State Insurance Commissioner and they have already sent a letter on my behalf to the insurance company. Thanks!

  • Comment on Sound Advocates PLLC's answer…
    171004_187797394575098_171125202908984_544001_2007695_o_small

    Also, you might find the results of a recent GAO report interesting. Apparently, health insurers reverse a significant number of claim denials upon appeal (at least in the states the study looked at).
    http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2014515695_apusinsurersclaimdenials.html

  • Comment on Russ Campbell, NWEBS's answer…
    Qlandav2ex_small

    This article was published today in the March 30th edition of The News Tribune concerning some of the recent actions taken by Insurance Commissioner Mike Kreidler. I thought you might find it encouraging about working with them.

    http://www.thenewstribune.com/2011/03/30/1606149/insurance-commissioner-has-fined.html

  • Comment on Kristin Bell's answer…
    Photo_on_2012-01-03_at_17

    Oh crap, I think I totally misunderstood your question. I was thinking insurance like health insurance, not the kind of insurance where you get a disability you get money. Sorry, I can't delete my question now!!! OY!

  • Comment on Rev.Enant's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    Thanks but no thanks Rev. I work two part time jobs, and I do in fact ride the bus to my white collar office job.

    My other job, however, requires a truck. Ergo, I require insurance.

  • Comment on keshmeshi's answer…
    Icon_small

    I'm also very suspicious about her only now sending you bills, and her claim that she wasn't paid "enough." Is that what she really said? That the insurance company didn't neglect to pay a bill for specific visits, that they instead didn't pay enough for each?