Ask Seattle A Question
Personal Finance
Answers
  • Is it wise to play the stock market on an individual basis?
    Min-wage_small

    It's possible to make money but you have to be comfortable with the possibility that you will lose some or all of your investment. The main criteria of whether you should buy individual stocks is not whether it's possible to make money, but whether you are comfortable with the greater risk that you will lose the money you invest. 401(k)s, IRAs, and index and mutual funds also carry some risk, but because they are diversified the rate of return (and perceived risk) has historically been better; however nothing is guaranteed unless it's FDIC or NCUA insured.

    There are many reasons rich people have a lot of money invested in the stock market - in general, they started out rich and can afford to lose the money; they can afford to hire a commission-based investment broker, who also has a personal interest in maximizing returns; they can buy many shares which provides more opportunity to make a profit at marginal gains; they can sell poorly-performing stocks at a loss to offset income; and the capital gains tax rate is much lower (max 15%) than the ordinary income tax rate (max 35%) at this time. The stock has to be held for more than one year to qualify as long-term for the capital gains tax rate, and it's possible that congress could change the capital gains tax regulations.

    I think if you have enough money to max out your annual 401k and/or IRA contributions, and have 6 months of living expenses in a savings account that you can easily access, and have extra money that wouldn't break your heart if you lost it, and treated stock investing as a hobby instead of a potential income source, you could have fun with it if you are comfortable with the risk. I think E-Trade is a popular site for self-investors but I've never researched it - really they just advertise a lot so I've heard of them. I don't know anything about minimums or fees involved.

    I will say that one benefit investing in stocks has over gambling is that even if you lose all your money you can use up to $3,000 of a net capital loss to offset your income on your tax return, which could potentially save you a few hundred dollars in taxes depending on your tax rate. So there is that one advantage over going to a casino.

  • Recommend a good debt consolidation or credit counseling agency?
    Hey_girl_hey_small

    You are much better off exploring bankruptcy options than going through a "credit counseling agency." Credit counseling and debt consolidation don't often work because your debtors are not legally bound to follow the agreements nor do they have to negotiate with the agency.

    A Chapter 13 Bankruptcy will allow to restructure your debts and pay them off without accruing more interest. Student loans work a little differently but you should still be able to include them in a Chapter 13.

    The Chapter 13 plan also allows you to immediately start rebuilding your credit and you have the force of law behind you.

    I used this attorney when I filed a number of years ago:

    http://www.seattle-bankruptcy-lawyers.com/

    They were competent and didn't cost too much.

  • Why is overpaying causing my interest payment to go up?
    Min-wage_small

    This applies to any loan: make your regular payment, and if you want to pay down the balance faster send a separate payment with written instructions to apply to the principal balance. The way you do this varies according to the lender, so you should contact their customer service and find out the best way to do this. Most lenders let you do this, although they make less money if you do so they don't make it easy. Also some loans will include pre-payment penalties - mostly car loans and mortgages - just something to be aware of in the future.

    Loan payments always apply to any late fees/charges first, then interest, then the principal. For the first several years of the loan your payments will apply almost entirely towards interest, because lenders don't calculate the interest every month like a credit card; they calculate it upfront and amortize the loan repayments so that you pay most or all of the interest first, then the principal. Also watch out for negative amortization with the income-based repayment plans - if your payments are less than the accrued interest, you get charged interest on the unpaid interest too.

    They do this because they make money on the interest payments, not the principal, so they want their revenue upfront. If you default and the loan gets written off, the lender can write off some or all of the loan principal as an expense for tax purposes, but the lost interest is just lost revenue.

    One thing to consider - the interest on student loans usually isn't that high, so you might not actually save much money paying down the balance on your student loan (unless it's private). You might be better off putting extra money in a savings account - it's really a good idea to have at least 3 months, preferably 6-12 months, of living expenses in something like a savings account or CD or combo of the two that you could access in case of an emergency. (This really helped me not completely freak out when I lost my job.) If you are planning on buying something expensive within the next few years, like a car, saving up ahead of time instead of taking out a loan will save you a lot of money in the future. Also putting any extra money towards retirement, either 401(k) or IRA accounts, might be a better investment than paying down your loan - it might not look that way on paper, but with compounding interest and tax breaks it could be eventually. But! If you are already doing these things, and don't have any credit card debt, then putting extra money towards the student loan principal is worth it.

  • Advantages of belonging to a credit union instead of a bank?
    Rex_racer_small

    #1 reason -- they aren't dicks strictly trying to take your money.
    in other words-- it's the difference between Bailey Savings & Loan vs. Old Man Potter.

    good ones --
    BECU.
    Alaskan CU
    Verity
    WSECU (if you can)

    All are good and all have been detailed to death here - just search those names in here and see.

  • I'm probably going to get cancer. How should I save up for it?
    Min-wage_small

    You'd want to talk to a professional to see if this would work for you, but maybe start saving with a Roth IRA? My understanding is that you could withdraw your contributions at any time without any tax penalty, and there are some situations where you could withdraw your earnings without a huge penalty. One situation is if you have unreimbursed medical expenses that are more than 10% of your adjusted gross income, you wouldn't have to pay the 10% penalty tax on the earnings if you've had the IRA for 5 years.

    The main advantage of an IRA over a savings account is that if you follow the rules you get a tax break - either in the year you contribute (traditional IRA) or when you get the earnings (Roth IRA). There is also a saver's credit if you are low to moderate income - check out IRS Publication 590 for details.

    Interest rates right now for any type of savings are crap, and will probably be crap for at least two years, so I think the tax advantages of an IRA will be helpful. I know that BECU has IRA CDs paying 0.95% interest for two years with at least $500 put in, which is a lot less of an initial investment than other places I've looked - you usually have to have $2500 to get started.

    If you don't have a savings account with three to six months of expenses saved up you should probably work on that first, or at least save for both at the same time. And make a plan to reduce debt, of course, if you have any.

    It really really sucks that we live in a society where people have to declare bankruptcy for medical bills. I hope that things will change so you won't have to worry about that - take care of yourself in the meantime, and make sure you're not scrimping so much that you don't have enough money to enjoy life.

  • What's the best credit union in Seattle?
    Min-wage_small

    Another vote for BECU! Super easy if you have direct deposit. If not, I'd go with the advice to pick a credit union with the most convenient branch for in-person deposits if you don't want to use a BECU or 7-11 ATM.

    Some benefits for BECU others haven't specifically mentioned:

    *Great rates with Member Advantage accounts without a lot of restrictions. I get 6% on the $1000 I keep in BECU.

    *Free external transfers - if you have accounts at more than one institution, you can put the routing and account numbers into BECU's external transfer system and move money yourself between banks/credit unions/whatever. Free for 3-day transfers.

    *Online deposits - actually kind of a pain, but if you scan the front & back of a check you can deposit it online and all or most of the money is available immediately just like ATM deposits.

    *BECU supports Express Credit Union, which serves low-income folks to help them save money.

    *Great rates for credit cards and line of credit, if you need them.

    With the co-op network I hardly ever have to pay ATM fees, and I can deposit checks at most 7-11 stores. When I travel I can usually find a free co-op ATM with a little planning. Also when I need to cash in change from my change jar I can go to the Eastlake WSECU and use their coin machine for free as a co-op member.

  • Escrow service needed, not real estate-related:
    Cappa_small

    https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Trustee

    If everyone can agree on a relative, family friend, lawyer, or other trusted and trustworthy person that's appropriate, you could try to establish a trust and make that person a trustee. Often, though, trustee responsiblities are hired out to a bank's trust department.

    Let's face it, banks can be pretty douchebaggerous, but maybe you'll have better luck with a local credit union:

    http://www.becu.org/wealth-management/trust-services.aspx
    206-812-5176 or 800-233-2328, ext. 5176 or becutrust@becu.org.

    Good luck.

  • Bus passes for the poor?
    Wa_usa_small

    You need to contact the Washington State Department of Social and Health Services (DSHS).

    Free passes are not distributed by Metro or Sound Transit, you're going to have to work with DSHS and navigate their alphabet soup of programs.

    Different programs have different requirements, but as a basic guideline, you need to be at or below the eligibility level to receive food stamps in order to get DSHS to buy you a bus pass.

    Under their Basic Food & Employment Training (BF E&T) program also known as Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP) DSHS will provide up to $100 for a bus pass.

    From the DSHS website:

    "BF E&T participants are eligible for a maximum $100 allowance per month for transportation or other costs related to participation. Bus passes and gas vouchers are allowed and will be paid by DSHS and the Employment Security Department (ESD) using the JOBS Automated System (eJAS)."

    Here's the thing about working with DSHS that you need to know, it's a giant monstrous shitty bureaucracy with a million stupid acronyms and little rules that are almost impossible for the layperson to interpret. But, most of the people who work there are really, really nice and helpful. So, just pick up the phone and give them a call: 1-877-501-2233

    Good luck!

  • Should I invest in gold or platinum coins?
    Medium_2868373187_b2c11c89cf_o_small

    This is one of the weirder questions I've seen asked - the profile photo of a obviously teenage boy, the odd over-the-top compliment to the U.S. Mint, and the question itself.

    Is this a stealth ad for U.S. mint investment?

    I think so.

  • debt consolidation vs bankruptcy?
    Bauhaus_small

    Student loans aren't wiped out in bankruptcy unless the borrower will never be able to repay - like if he/she has become permanently disabled. The good news is that President Obama has gotten the ICR and IBR repayment plans through the Congress while the Dems were still in charge. It changes everything about repayment. Check it out if you haven't already.

    I'm with Dan. Bankruptcy will cost you about $400-$1200 to file, but it will clear your record. Some of the debt consolidating agencies will cost as much and are pretty damn shady keeping up to 80 percent of your payment for fees. Most are bankrolled by the credit card companies, so that's where their interest lies. They don't give a crap about you beyond wanting to get payback.

    Bankruptcy is a federal action and held in federal court. It is spelled out in the US Constitution, born by the founding fathers who remembered the days when people were thrown into debtors' prisons and workhouses. It allows people to get a fresh start when things go horribly wrong financially. And even though some take advantage of the process, there is no shame in being poor and wanting to get a fresh start - irrespective of what those debt consolidation ads say on TV. I'm sure you've heard the statistics about the vast majority of bankruptcy cases these days being people who were just barely making ends meet when they were hit with a $100,000 medical bill.

    You can DIY for around $400-$500 (the filing fee) but the paper work is pretty complex and taxing. You have to list EVERYTHING you owe to EVERYBODY. Doable if you don't have a ton of creditors. There are affordable lawyers out there who will do it for under $1000 if the bankruptcy is simple enough. Most want around $1200 last I heard. They'll file all your papers and notify all creditors that a petition for bankruptcy has been filed and that all collection actions must cease from this moment on. In other words, filing for bankruptcy puts an immediate end to all attempts to collect.

    Good luck, Avi!

  • Should I cash out my 401K to buy a house?
    6521205-0-large_small

    The way you are phrasing the question one would think this is really a math problem i.e how much will you lose in early withdrawal vs. the gains in a tax deductible mortgage. But it isn't.

    Your 401k is your retirement fund. You will need it at some point in the future and the longer you have it, the more it will grow.

    Perhaps you are assuming that your house is an alternative form of saving for retirement. While there is some basis for that assumption historically, it's potentially no longer true. Don't mess with your 401k, find another way.

    To add to the risk, there is a growing movement towards a tax system which would remove mortgages from being tax deductible.

    It is a good time to get mortgage since the rates are incredibly low and unlikely to stay that way. But the best thing to do is to find a way without touching your 401k.

Questions
Recent Comments
  • Comment on Malcolmxy's answer…
    Cats_small

    I get a 1.55% on a CD that I can add money to. SECUW offers 0.15% on savings of $500+. Twice a month I have a set amount transfer from my checking to my "add to" CD. Unfortunately, it's tough to find a local rate over 1.0% for balances between $500-$10,000.

    The fee for liquidating early is 3 months worth of accrued interest, and that is all.

    I can transfer funds (partial, full, interest only) from the CD to either my checking or savings account online.

    It was harder to get money out of my ING savings than it will be to get money out of my BECU CD's.

  • Comment on Tracy M's answer…
    Cats_small

    You can now get debit cards printed on the spot. They're no longer pressed w/ raised numbers.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Avatar_default

    I would agree that quickbooks is by far the most widely used software for accountants but what I had a question about was what kind of degrees do accountants have to have now days to get a good role within an accounting firm. I feel that quickbooks is not that hard to use and I have also talked to numerous people that say they are hiring people now without having your standard masters degree in accounting/finance. As someone commented on earlier they are taking an accounting class at a community college and feels that quickbooks is very simple to manage. I know people that are looking at programs to complete certificates in accounting instead of getting their bachelors/masters. http://accountingcertificateprograms.net/ is a good example of the kind of programs that are available now for people that want to get into finance and accounting.

    Its very interesting though that people even in this forum talk about how they are going to a community college for accounting and I am curious to see how they fair amongst the accounts that completed masters degrees. Either way back on the subject I would have to say quickbooks is the way to go in terms of easiest to use as well as most commonly used.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    I'm not in WA right now but I'm planning on moving back in June. I'm also going to open a Vanguard account within the month. Thanks so much for all the great information. I really do appreciate it.

    I guess I was hoping to make some money investing in the short term but it looks as though that's just not possible. Saving for retirement is a whole different beast but I do plan start a 401k once it's offered to me and probably additional savings depending on what's going on.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Min-wage_small

    I know the interest rates suck right now, but it's important to keep some money set aside in a safe account - the security is more important than making money on your emergency fund. The interest rates aren't going to get better in the next couple of years, but you can do better than .05%.

    Are you in Washington state? I have accounts at BECU (Member Advantage Checking and Savings) and Seattle Metropolitan CU (Feel Good Checking) that pay 6% interest each on the first $500, so I'm using them as my emergency fund savings accounts for $1500.

    I have an online savings account for anything over that - I'm using Discover but there's also ING Direct. They're pretty easy to set up, and right now they're paying 0.80 - 0.85%.

    To get the higher interest rate on the credit union accounts, all I need is to get e-statements and have direct deposit. Since direct deposit's not available through my current job, I just use my online savings account to make small transfers every month into my credit union accounts and that satisfies the direct deposit requirement.

    Anyways, that's just one thing you can do with your savings. If you're not in Washington look for a credit union where you are - they might have similar interest rates.

    As far as investments, if you have a 401(k) with matching available through work that's really one of the best deals - you want to get the maximum match from your employer because it's basically free money.

    You don't need to hire an investment broker on your own - BECU and SMCU have investment advisors who can give guidance, and there's also Vanguard or Fidelity. I haven't used any of them but I think they offer similar services - they'll tell you the potential risks and benefits, and you can probably choose from index, mutual, and/or bond funds. You can also choose to have these funds as part of your IRA, or do a mix of funds and CD's (which are insured) as part of your IRA.

    Make sure you find out what all the fees are before you invest, because they can really eat into your return. I think that's one reason a lot of people recommend index funds over mutual funds right now.

    If you're still interested in the stock market, check out corporate bonds and/or preferred stock in addition to common stock - maybe also municipal bonds, if you have the minimum buy-in. Muni bonds don't pay the best interest, but the interest is tax-free.

    Investopedia has some basic info about a lot of choices: http://www.investopedia.com/university/20_investments/default.asp#axzz1q9q1DsVn

  • Comment on Kip Waddle's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    That's the answer I suspected I would get.I guess my fear is that eventually the market will crash again and 401ks will lose their value. But then again, if that happens stock values drop as well.

    @Tom Sackett. I wanted to buy some U.S. bonds but the interest rates are ridiculous. 3% over 30 years is not a good rate. But I'm setting up an IRA this week and eventually I'll have a 401k.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Yeah, I wonder if I'll ever have quite enough money to do as you recommend. I guess that's kinda why I was interested. I have some money in a savings account but it's just sitting getting .05% interest. I wish I could find some way to make it work for me. But you're right at the same time. I can't afford at all to lose my savings. I would be screwed. And I know that I'm too poor to hire an investment broker.

  • Comment on Christina L's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    It's cool. I'm just parroting the news articles that I read that tend to use play when they talk about the market.

    Thank you for the book recommendations and links. I will check them out when I have the time and before I actually do anything with money.

  • Comment on Russ Campbell, NWEBS's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Looks pretty interesting! Once I get back to Seattle, I'll have to think about it. Thank you for the recommendation.

  • Comment on Tom Sackett's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Thank you. Yeah, I suspected that it was pretty risky. I hadn't heard of index funds though, perhaps I should learn more about them.

  • Comment on Tom Sackett's answer…
    0prr6_small

    The idea that the average performance of stock brokers is not better than the indexes is worse than it sounds. Lots of brokers do much better. Those that do are successful enough to limit their clients to the wealthy. Those who take small accounts are inexperienced or relatively unsuccessful. The chance of finding someone who is talented enough to make you more money than a mutual fund is very, very small if you have less than $100,000 to invest.

    The chance that an individual buying stocks could do better than that is ridiculously small over the long run.

  • Comment on Kip Waddle's answer…
    N871065272_8115_small

    That's a clearer (and probably better) answer than mine. I would also add the following:
    1. Use investing to save for retirement, rather than income. There are a couple other long-range goals, like education or buying a house that may let you take advantage of "retirement" type investments.
    2. In addition to 401ks, which are provided by your employer. You can use IRAs from other institutions. There are a couple of different types of IRAs, which have different amounts of flexibility or tax consequences.
    3. Index funds may be a better option than managed funds. Even when they don't perform as well, they usually have much lower fees. Both are options in a 401k or IRA plan.
    4. The closer you are to retirement (or some other long-term goal) the less money should be in stock-based funds (like the ones mentioned above), and the more money should be in risk-free investments, like bonds.

  • Comment on elm's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    I have had the experience where my bank will cash anything, as long as I have the money in my account to cover it.

    Years ago, I took an outdated refund check for $5 to a strange bank, and asked the young teller if I could cash it. Despite it clearly being beyond the valid date, she did. I took the money and ran, never looking back. Don't know if she got in trouble or not. I didn't lie or mislead at all. Just asked if I could cash it with ID.

  • Comment on IsadoraWing's answer…
    Kendo_20dog_small

    Of course I skipped right over the results that would have helped you. If you search for "INTERNAT ACOUSTIGRAPH COMPANY" on Google, you should find several patents from your mystery company. It looks like they made sound recording devices and loudspeakers. Some of the patents for cone shaped speakers look remarkably similar to designs that are still used today.

    The unusual name probably comes from a story by Jean Ingelow. She wrote about a device for recording and replaying music before such a concept seemed feasible. "UNITED ACOUSTIGRAPH CORP" looks like a competing company with similar products.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Avatar_default

    Yes, Paypal was a good way to go. Also, www.XE.com. My friend cancelled the transaction, but I found out that BECU doesn't charge any fee for the recipient of a wire transfer, so that probably was the way I was going to go. Paypay may have been cheaper, I don't know, but I preferred the solution where all the banking-type costs were borne by the person who was sending me the money. Thanks!

  • Comment on Russ Campbell, NWEBS's answer…
    Qlandav2ex_small

    My transfer was pre-Paypal use so it would be good to compare them. If you already have a Paypal account it will undoubtably be easier to go that route. You do pay a premium for exchange between currencies and that method has to be acceptable for the receiver.

    Good call, Tom.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Min-wage_small

    You should still call them and ask, but I just remembered that you can payoff your loan early, and it should be cheaper in the long run.

    Log into your account and click on "View Payoff Details." That should give you a lower total than if you made all your payments; it might be that you can only do a one-time payoff instead of paying down the principal.

    If that's true, then just put the money you would send as an extra payment into a separate designated savings account until you have enough saved to do the payoff. (That total will slowly get lower over time.)

    Yeah you would think they would want their money back ASAP, but the federal loans need to make some money to pay some of the operating expenses, kind of like a non-profit.

  • Comment on stu's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    I poke around the website looking for that option but maybe I can't find it until I'm actually making a payment. I'll check again next time. It would be lovely if there was an option like that.

  • Comment on O my captain's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Wow, that's awful! Talk about being punished for being financially responsible.

    I'll see what I can do or if I can do anything. I might have to just be stuck and put the extra in savings instead.

  • Comment on Luckier's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    I'll look into this and see if it's an option and if they'll actually take it. I'd hate to send a check and have them run off with it.

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Yeah, I was hoping that by paying off my loan quickly I could end up paying less in interest over the long haul. And I can see how forcing the loanee to pay off the interest first makes sense even if it sucks. XD

    I guess I hoped that since it was a gov school loan, they'd just be happy to get their money back as quickly as possible. But I will see what I can do. I'm suspecting that there won't be much.

  • Comment on Russ Campbell, NWEBS's answer…
    Atessoue_small

    Damn. Well I guess I'll have to call them and see what I can do. I checked the site and haven't found any reliable info about lump payments unless its' paid before the loan goes into repayment. Thanks for the tip about getting it in writing. I can see how not having it would really backfire.

  • Comment on Dan Williams's answer…
    N679371400_3703_small

    Hey all, much thanks! Student loans are less of a worry, and I think I can sort the rest out based on this excellent advice.

  • Comment on rickibot's answer…
    N679371400_3703_small

    Good advice Rickibot. Thank you sincerely!

  • Comment on Mahtli69's answer…
    6521205-0-large_small

    Actually, that's very helpful. I'd come to the conclusion that the GET plan now sucked, so that helps confirm that.

    I ended up doing going with the Michigan plan managed by TIAA-CREF. It's a very flexible plan that has performed very well and adjusts investment strategy automatically based on age of child. The min/max contributions are great and the plan can be used in any state and even rolled over to another state should WA get its act together.

  • Comment on Dan Williams's answer…
    6521205-0-large_small

    I agree 100%. Attorneys are a much better way to go. The "credit counselors" have been reviewed as scam artists on many a news show I have watched.

  • Comment on Dan Williams's answer…
    Hey_girl_hey_small

    That is my general understanding also, but I believe it is possible to incorporate student loans into 100% payback Chapter 13 cases, at least according to what I read on the internets. I was fortunate to not have any student loan debt, just unsecured consumer debt when I did a Chapter 13.

    Regardless, consulting a bankruptcy attorney first would be my advice. Most offer free consultations and will give you a better opinion than most "credit counselors."

  • Comment on Dan Williams's answer…
    6521205-0-large_small

    My understanding is that it's pretty hard to get rid of student loan, even in bankruptcy. The argument being that you will accrue the benefits for life and so they cannot reclaim or liquidate the asset.

    It is possible if you can show undue hardship, but it's a different test than normally applied in bankruptcy.

    Did you manage to get rid of student loan?

  • Comment on asteria's answer…
    Min-wage_small

    I forgot about the Bank On Seattle-King County website - http://www.everyoneiswelcome.org/ They have a search engine - Find a Bank or Credit Union. You put in your zipcode, how much money you have to open the account, and if you select "I still owe money from a previous overdraft with a bank or credit union" you'll find places that are more likely to let you open an account. Select "more than $100" to get the biggest list of results.

    Express is the only credit union that came up, but there are a few banks like HomeStreet, Seattle Bank and Banner Bank. When you click on the bank name you get a pdf of their answers to questions; one of the questions is whether they let people open accounts who are in the Chex System.

    You're probably not in the Chex System - people who have a lot of NSF checks and their account gets closed are in Chex. But banks or credit unions that let people in the Chex System open accounts will probably let you open an account too.

  • Comment on Tom Sackett's answer…
    Min-wage_small

    If you are able to open a savings account, be sure to ask about withdrawal limits. A lot of savings accounts only let you make 6 withdrawals in a month for free; any withdrawals after that may be charged a fee.