Ask Seattle A Question
Fish & Seafood
20110126-xa322xyr5n7srudi9gyry3xnwa

Situated on the North Pacific and surrounded by mountain rivers and lakes, Seattle is a fish and seafood heaven. Ask about where to buy fish, how to prepare it, what to pair with it. Ask which fish to avoid for health or sustainability reasons. Ask ab...

Answers
  • Are there any Community Supported Fisheries (CSF) active in the Puget Sound region?
    Oyster_bill_cropped_small

    At this time, there are no active CSF in the area. There have been a few attempts to start one, but were not successful. I know that other areas in the US have successful CSFs, but unfortunately none around the Puget Sound region. Shopping at your local farmers markets are your best choice, with the Ballard, University District, and West Seattle markets operating year round.

  • Where is the best seafood shop to buy oysters?
    Oyster_bill_cropped_small

    The best place, hands down, to buy local oysters is the Taylor Shellfish Farms new retail store on Capitol Hill! It's located at 1521 Melrose Ave. in the Melrose Market building between Pike & Pine. There's a large variety of oysters, plus manila clams, Mediterranean mussels, geoduck, live scallops, Dungeness crab, and Maine lobster. Hot oyster stew and geoduck chowder as well! There is no other store like this in Seattle. Stop by and have some oysters and a glass of wine, then choose your fresh shellfish to prepare at home. Nothing better!

  • Can you ship crab?
    Img_3380_small

    AHH! The frozen king crab you buy at the market IS COOKED.

    I worked for a seafood processing/packaging plant in AK for three years, and a good portion of our business was mail order king crab. It was absolutely, always, 100% cooked as soon as it came off the boats. The "story" about crab becoming poisonous once it dies (if not cooked) is absolutely true.

    When we shipped ours it was cooked immediately, flash frozen, and shipped overnight with gel ice packs. Dry ice should work fine too as long as you really protect the crab from direct contact.

    The best way to warm it back up once frozen is to allow it to thaw in the fridge overnight, then quickly steam it in a large pot, just until warm. Or just eat it cold.

    Fun story about dead crab- we once had a fisherman offload an entire boat of dead king crab on a Friday afternoon. The plant manager let it sit over the weekend and by Monday morning the smell coming out of the building was so pungent we were all sick trying to work in the front office. I had to get rid of all of the clothes I wore that first week. Mmm. One crab had died and poisoned the entire load. Nasty and awful.

  • Where is the cheapest place to buy fish fillets?
    Cateyes_small

    Uwajimaya, hands down. Their fish selection is top notch, and cheap. They specialize in sashimi-grade cuts of fish, but you'll definitely be able to find what you're looking for. In addition, most fish counters should de-bone fish for you, if you ask them.

    Note to others: Uwajimaya also has fresh oysters for $6-8/dozen, which is basically a third cheaper than you can get them anywhere else.

  • What does sushi taste like? and if I don't normally like fish, would I have any chance of liking sushi?
    N815394_32920449_260_small

    Sushi tastes like heaven. That said, you probably wouldn't like yellow tail or mackerel or any of the really "fishy" tasting fish. Philidelphia rolls (salmon and cream cheese) are pretty good for people who don't much like fish. Eel is a little more daring, but it's very sweet, almost like dessert. Fresh tuna is great.
    A good way to do beginner sushi is to just ask your waiter. Or go with a good friend who likes sushi and have them order.
    I go by the policy that you should try everything twice. Go for it! What's the worst that can happen, you don't like it and don't order it again. There's always california rolls.

Questions
Recent Comments
  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Qlandav2ex_small

    Thanks, Oyster Bill, I have appreciated your posts here and am happy to give you the 'Shroom for this one. Tom filled in the name of a local fishing family selling at those markets.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Qlandav2ex_small

    Tom,
    Thanks for a great answer. I too, have had that opportunity to buy good fish in a private sale from a local fisherman, but I have not seen that fellow for a few years. The reference to Loki is great (they have a good website) and I see they sell at the farmer's markets where Oyster Bill directed me.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Subcultureoftwo_small

    Kayakers are your mortal enemies? Do tell.

  • Comment on DosWheeler's answer…
    Photo_on_2011-05-23_at_16

    I second Taylor Shellfish. The staff is awesome, and they have about 5-8 different species of oysters all the time. You can looks at them, and even watch them being shucked. Or bring them home and shuck them yourself!
    My favorite part is they have like geoduck that you can actually touch. It's creepy and gross and awesome.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Cateyes_small

    Ha! Awesome. :)

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Finn3goof_small

    I don't think I ever actually blushed from a post before.

    But I'm afraid I am married with child and one on the way.

    Thanks, though! that made my day.

  • Comment on Tom's answer…
    Cateyes_small

    Uh, are you single? This sounds like the best date idea I've ever heard.

  • Comment on sublevelthree's answer…
    Img_5852_small

    Yep, it's a choking hazard. (It's also a "eating something that has bones" hazard, if you ask me). Additionally, some folks are very squeamish about their food and don't want to be reminded where animal products come from. A few years ago, moved into a new neighborhood. Took my friends who were helping me paint to dinner at local mexican place. My sister found a chicken bone in the quesadilla and it FREAKED her out. The rest of us were kinda impressed, as it implied they used real chickens and not processed scary meat product, but she was too icked out. (Probably didn't help that I kept chanting "Bone-y Bone-y Bone-y" and wiggling the 2" bone in her direction *laughs*)

  • Comment on sublevelthree's answer…
    Ava_small

    You can snap the bone easily when chewing it and make the edge sharper and it can cause lots o hurt to you're mouth, let alone if you swallow it

  • Comment on sublevelthree's answer…
    Michiko_small

    But if you actually chewed on the fish, you would find the bone, and not choke on it.

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Michiko_small

    Just wanted to report back to you guys... the dungeness was phoenomenal! Seriously, one of the best I've ever had. That guy was huge and so sweet. And the shigoku oysters were amazing--new favorite!

    This is going to be a great winter for my tummy :p

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    PS - Great answer Oyster Bill, thanks for the info. I did not know this shop existed in the city!

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    Yeah I just confirmed with my boyfriend in Westport, the coastal fishermen haven't even started yet. There should be even more Dungies on the market soon. Enjoy!

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Michiko_small

    soundslikepuget, that is exciting news, Dungeness is my favorite food ever!

    Oyster Bill, thanks for the tip.

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    This has been the best year I have ever seen for Dungies on Puget Sound. And I don't even think the Coastal season has really gotten underway yet. It was delayed, until late December and the fishermen usually strike until the processors give a higher price, so the coastal stuff probably isn't in stock yet, but when it starts coming it should be off the hook

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Oyster_bill_cropped_small

    They should have a pretty good supply coming in tomorrow for the weekend. I would go in on Friday and select what you want, maybe even leave a deposit, and they can hold your order for you in the live tanks until you pick them up on Saturday.

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Michiko_small

    Hey Oyster Bill, the oyster and crab are for christmas dinner. You think it would fine to pick them up tomorrow or should i wait until saturday?

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Photo_small

    I second Taylor! They also have delicious mussels at a very reasonable price. We got 3 pounds the other day and it was more than enough for our main dinner course for a family of 4.

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Michiko_small

    Yay, you're my hero!

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Oyster_bill_cropped_small

    Yes, the Dungeness crab are huge now, sweet and fat! We had some that were over three pounds the other day. They're coming in from Nisqually Reach in south sound. GO!

  • Comment on Oyster Bill's answer…
    Michiko_small

    Ooooh, I haven't been to this shop. This sounds like my kind of place!

    Do they have awesome dungeness crab there? I like them big and fat.

  • Comment on capicola's answer…
    14343_1175549625459_1129622245_30417368_3760566_n_small

    I called, they do still have it daily, and the best part is, this is very near my home. PERFECT!

  • Comment on RM's answer…
    Img_3380_small

    Thanks for the mushroom! I get a little excited about fishy things sometimes.

    And that is GREAT to hear! We may be going back this coming weekend. I love it there.

  • Comment on RM's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    Brilliant! Thanks for the "Inside baseball" information from a former crab processor!!

    PS - I went to Guemes Island this weekend for the first time and used your blog as a handy dandy guide! Thanks!

  • Comment on soundslikepuget's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    @Sacrelicious I was NOT aware of that. Cool beans.

  • Comment on Dan Williams's answer…
    Froggyskull_3_small

    They also have a free "Seafood Watch" iPhone app. I don't know if it's available for the other smart phone systems.

  • Comment on soundslikepuget's answer…
    Subcultureoftwo_small

    Hey Puget,

    Nope, it's totally true. I work with IDFG people every day and I've personally witnessed it and talked with them about it (they don't make it widely known). I CAN confirm that it's certainly not willy-nilly. The fish techs that maintain the screw traps also do line sampling (catch and release) for spawning Chinook and steelhead in spring and fall. The fish they catch are weighed and measured, and they take a scale sample before letting them go. If it's a hatchery fish (anal fin missing), they kill it and put it back in the water (they're not legally allowed to eat them, interestingly...that nitrogen goes back into the riparian system). So, there's some reduction of hatchery genes (in order to give the wild genes a better shot at it), but I'm sure the overall impact is quite minimal.

    I'm sure that some of the hatchery fish are harvested at the dams for their milt and eggs, but it doesn't happen this far up the system.

    Finally, I'm sure that fishing laws are WILDLY different from state to state, so I would have been just as skeptical in your place. I'm not a fisherman or hunter myself, but occasionally I'll page through my annual books of hunting regs. I usually get about 10 minutes of reading before I go googly-eyed.

    Cheers!

  • Comment on soundslikepuget's answer…
    Wa_usa_small

    @Kristin Bell, good question.

    @Sacrelecious, you're right about the first part. Hatchery fish are an important part of the strategy to keep our wild fisheries sustainable, by augmenting the stocks impaired by the hydropower dams that supply our region's electricity, and decades of damage in previous generations from overfishing.

    As to the second part of your answer, I'm a bit skeptical, however. As a Washington fisherman, I'm not familiar with the intricacies of how Idaho Department of Fish & Game operates, but I doubt that they are out there just killing the hatchery fish willy nilly. I suspect they probably harvest the eggs and milt from hatchery fish, and combine them to raise a new generation of hatchery salmon. That's the standard operating procedure for most fishery management agencies. Perhaps you know something about Idaho that I don't however.

    As a fisherman, I've practically had to earn a Ph.D. in bureaucratic bullshit to understand all the rules the Washington Department of Fish & Wildlife requires that we read and understand. The WA regulation book for fishermen was 133 pages this year, so I hope you'll understand if my brain is full from that and I'm wrong about Idaho ;)

  • Comment on internet_jen's answer…
    N510833790_3563_small

    Farmed fish don't necessarily have to be bad. American farm raised catfish are a great choice. Most of the freshwater farmed fish (Tilapia, Trout, Sturgeon, Barramundi, Artic Char) are probably more sustainable than wild caught fish. You just have to be vigilant about checking where the farm is. American and Canadian farms are usually fine, but if it comes from Asia, avoid it.

    Also, most shellfish (crawfish, oysters, mussels, clams, and scallops) are better than the wild caught versions. There are even some good farmed shrimp now, but it's very hard to tell them from the bad versions.

  • Comment on soundslikepuget's answer…
    Subcultureoftwo_small

    Nope. Farmed fish are raised and harvested in a confined fish farm. Hatchery fish are salmonids that are hatched at the hatchery, but then released into the wild to go do their own thing. Hatchery fish are meant to augment the wild salmon populations for fisherman. When IDFG catches a hatchery salmon trying to spawn upstream, they kill it in order to preserve wild genes.