Ask Seattle A Question
Questions are no longer being accepted in this category. You can read previous questions and answers below.
SIFF
5713392603_042e768830_m

The Seattle International Film Festival is one of the few things that distinguishes Seattle as a world class city. Clinton McClung is a programmer for the festival, and knows everything there is to know about the films this year and the nuts and bolts...

Answers
  • Does SIFF screen films before selecting them for the festival? Or do you base decisions off of trailers and written descriptions?
    Img_0779_small

    We do indeed watch everything, not all of us, but usually at least three programmers (with occasional films being selected by Carl & Beth, our head programmers, and some of our other collaborators). There's more about that process here:
    http://questionland.com/questions/20382-what-criteria-in-addition-to-critics-approval-get-a-film-added-to-a-program

    "The Penitent Man" was certainly one of the more divisive films last year, but there were some people who really liked it (at least according to the reviews on our website). I personally didn't champion the film, but understand what it was going for - a scifi think piece that was all about conversation, and not so much about the plot. It was also locally produced, and part of our mission is to spotlight local filmmakers. I will say that it was a more rewarding film experience for those who stayed for a Q&A with the director.

    But the truth about any festival is that there will be one or two films that are total head-scratchers. I've visited a lot of festivals over the years, and there is always one program where I am left wondering why it was chosen. That is what makes festivals different from seeing regular theatrical release films. Festivals tend to represent films that have something unique about them that may (or may not) appeal to audiences. Truth be told, you never know until you see a film with an audience what the reaction will be - and no two audiences react in the same way.

  • What criteria in addition to critics' approval get a film added to a program?
    Img_0779_small

    We have a slew of programmers, and it usually takes a thumbs up grade from at least three of us for a film to be considered for the festival - and even then a lot of debate tends to ensue. We don't base selections on stars, reviews, or directors (though some directors make truly interesting films, even when they feel like misfires), but on the overall quality of the film and if our SIFF audience will appreciate it. That said, there are all kinds of SIFF audiences, and films that some people find boring, others love. Not every film will be a gem for everyone who watches it, but we hope that the right films will find the right audiences and they will make a connection.

    And I personally tend to ignore the reviews - especially from films that have played at other festivals - because sometimes the reviews are only partly about the movie, and partly about the expectations and their relation to other festival films. As a long time fest binger, I have often times experienced a films that I didn't enjoy when I first saw it because I had just hit that sensory overload point of seeing 5 films a day (as many critics do when doing festivals). But then on later reflection I really grow to love it.

    But seriously, what film were you thinking of? I'll give you an honest answer!

Questions
Recent Comments
  • Comment on Chris Coronado's answer…
    Avatar_default

    Detention
    TEENS! MUSIC! DEATH! 1990S! SEX! FUCK! SHIT! BEAR! TEENS! MOVIES! POP CULTURAL REFERENCES! THE FLY! WTF?! MORE DEATH! MORE REFERENCES! HIGH SCHOOL! BEAR AGAIN! BOMB! PROM! DEATH! EVEN MORE POP CULTURE REFERENCES! END!

  • Comment on Chris Coronado's answer…
    Avatar_default

    Wasted on the Young
    A non-funny mashup of Cruel Intentions and The Virgin Spring. Vigilante justice meets the rape-revenge genre in the fractured reality of modern youth. The main flaws lie in the hands of the first time director, who tries too hard to play with the medium in ways we've already seen. The techno soundtrack is brilliant, but it doesn't quite make up for the movie's fuzzy morality and not-quite-confident storytelling. The director is somebody to look out for once he gets his legs.

  • Comment on Chris Coronado's answer…
    Avatar_default

    High Road
    Generic road movie meets pot-laced humor and improv as directed by Upright Citizen Brigade's Matt Walsh. Like all good improv comedy before it, it has both high points and low points, but what makes this movie work is its heart. What makes this movie almost fail is its surprising number of gay jokes (is this still 2011?). Toke up and you'll probably love it.

  • Comment on Kim Stockbridge's answer…
    Small_small

    20+ people walked out within the first 20mins of the press screening for this movie. Majority felt uncomfortable with the graphic male on male loving. I don't mind that at all, just the quality of the movie wasn't that great. Too bad...

    NSFW NSFW NSFW!!!! YouTube Trailer for the movie.
    http://youtu.be/kXKNv36Exyc

  • Comment on Explorer's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    Can you translate that for us?

  • Comment on Kim Stockbridge's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    Now you've got me wondering about this one... is there any oportunity to see some of these, even clips, after the fact?

  • Comment on kitschnsync's answer…
    Image00666_small

    Mama Africa

    Well before Nelson Mandela was a name known around the world, Miriam Makeba testified before the United Nations on South African apartheid. It was a fitting honor for a woman whose pioneering musical career eventually spanned 50 years and multiple continents. Mama Africa details Makeba’s involvement in the civil rights struggles of Africa and America, but the soul of the movie can be found in the footage of her performances. Makeba’s love of music and Africa comes through in every note; Finnish director Mika Kaurismäki wisely lets her voice stand on its own.

  • Comment on kitschnsync's answer…
    Image00666_small

    Without

    Shot on Whidbey Island by Seattle native Mark Jackson, Without is 90 minutes of despair and boredom against an emerald background. Young Joslyn takes a job on the island as a live-in caregiver for Frank, a man trapped in a persistent vegetative state. As Joslyn spends her time with Frank in isolation, she processes unresolved feelings about her last relationship, which ended in tragedy. While Jackson clearly wants to impress a feeling of boredom upon the viewer, he does it a little too well. The story moves slowly, and several plot points are left unexplained. You’ll leave unsatisfied.

  • Comment on kitschnsync's answer…
    Image00666_small

    Huh. I guess Qland doesn't like cut and paste from Word. I'll format correctly below.

    Also, I'm commenting on my own answer!

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    Image00666_small

    Yeah, but doesn't somebody have to comment on your answer before you can?

    Anyway, I'll put up a couple...

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    Gold-head_small

    Or you can review as a comment to your earlier answer.

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    N14502962_31052994_3896_small

    kitschnsync:

    Do not fret! If this first round goes well, I'm planning to put up a new post for next week's entries, and the week after that.

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    Image00666_small

    I'd like to contribute, but maybe this question should wait until SIFF starts winding down.

    Given the structure of Qland, anyone who comments won't be able to add reviews for movies that they see later in the festival. June 12 is more than two weeks away!

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    Photo_small

    Hey Lindy, You're can only post 1 answer to a question on Questionland so the way EricD did it is the best way to post multiple reviews.

  • Comment on EricD's answer…
    N14502962_31052994_3896_small

    UPDATE: The thing I wrote earlier was wrong because I know nothing. Write as many as you like, and put them all in one answer!

    (Thanks to Marty Unger, below.)

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    N634983527_555761_5377_small

    My last contribution to this thread, it's been informative and an interesting dialog, so thank you all. It seems that myself and a few others here aren't the only ones expressing a similar sentiment in asking these questions: http://queenannenews.com/main.asp?SectionID=83&SubSectionID=404&ArticleID=31553

  • Comment on Steve Schonberger's answer…
    Spaceship_small

    I'm SO happy for you both! FILM the wedding!

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    27434_1054177919_2296_n_small

    All true. And, NOW, a little well-deserved Ass-Kissing, for YOU and ALL the SIFF Staff!!! I JUST typed Kissing, NOT Kicking, right?

    Y'all are VERY user-friendly!!! AND I'm not referring to the technology, necessarily. BUT to the Human / Humanity Factor. I can REMEMBER the Old Days. NOT so MUCH. Often, worst at top, where the Culture was set. In Stone. Marble. NOT Sandstone. Could get pretty Bumpy, as Ms. Davis would WANT us to say.

    BUT, that often Hard, Cold, NOT-Fuzzy Beginning made for an Enduring, Reputable Foundation. It HAD to be Rough-Going, in those Blazing, Unforgiving Early Years, when Other Festivals could / did, Falter AND Fail.

    I thank Darryl and Dan, loud AND long, whenever necessary to defend their often Moat w/gators Protection of Castle SIFF. Tweren't a task for the faint-of-heart.

    Most GREAT, enduring institutions go thru some grueling times. You've started infrastructure changes to Lady SIFF, and she's looking good.

    THX! Again and STILL, for YOUR Effort & Devotion. Envelope, please.

    And a tissue.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    Img_0779_small

    It's okay. There are a lot of ins and outs to festival and film booking, and I understand the frustrations from people on the outside looking in. You want to see these films, darnit! I too wish we could play everything that we want -- and that we could extend the festival, oh, another two months so we could include even more films. Ah, but that might be overkill.

    By the way, I should mention that SIFF is expanding our year-round programming thanks to the new SIFF Film Center that will be opening in the fall. We'll have a lot more opportunity to play smaller films that may not make the festival, but still need a home in Seattle. So keep your eyes peeled for even more international cinema, indie films, and documentaries year round.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    27434_1054177919_2296_n_small

    Clinton, you've elucidated on, basically, the SAME issue, here, 3 Or MORE Times, with admirable restraint, candor and insight.

    I've a suggestion for those are genuinely perplexed, VERY FILM-Devotees of SIFF. VOLUNTEER at SIFF, during off-season.

    If Clinton DARES reveal ANY Deeper Wisdom in the FILM-getting World, Competitors WILL read his responses to YOUR fine Queries, STEAL His Formulas, and YOU will see even LESS Greats at SIFF. Ach!

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    Img_0779_small

    Sometimes that is precisely why we don't get a film, because it is already playing at another festival near our date, or because the distributor feels that they have enough festival exposure.

    The festival world is pretty competitive (and with more and more festivals in the world, more so today than it ever has been). Sometimes we'll "lose" a film to another festival, sometimes we get it before anyone else, sometimes we have to negotiate away one film in order to get another. That's just the way it works. Wish we could just point at any film we want and say "you're IN!", but there is a lot of behind the scenes negotiation that needs to happen to play most films.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    Hemingway460_small

    I'm rather curious about one thing still. These gentlemen, and I checked on what they say cause I don't know San Fransisco that well, but there are films that SF festival plays that don't end up in SIFF. Films from MAJOR international filmmakers. Films that many film lovers want to see that don't make it to SIFF. I don't understand how or why they're made available to SF and not Seattle. I don't claim to know your job, but perhaps that's what this is all about right! Can you explain why SF can play those films and Seattle can't? It just doesn't make any sense to me.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    Img_5852_small

    TeenTix is a GREAT program. And remember, once your son ages out of that, many of the theatres offer $25 (or so) tickets to those under 25.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    Avatar_default

    I love that this app exists, but it quit on me halfway through posting my schedule as events to Facebook. I too would appreciate its being optimized for iPad.

    This is the first year I've tried using it, and I've defaulted to My SIFF.

    Like it, but wish it were more reliable and up-to-date.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    N634983527_555761_5377_small

    Thank you Clinton, for taking the time to address these queries.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    27434_1054177919_2296_n_small

    THX for yer effort!

    BUT she raises an interesting FACTOID ... the tickets are [entirely] in same price-range, so MAYBE they oughta be in FSPass. Why NOT? Could ALSO, then, be viewed as a further Tool to INCREASE sales of those Passes.

    AND, Clinton, my comment is NOT dismissive of Your effort to expand THAT availability, but just supportive, AND underlining her fact .... more ammo for your campaign, on Our behalf. G'day

  • Comment on Steve Schonberger's answer…
    27434_1054177919_2296_n_small

    Could you put a Yellow Sticky on that Special Best Mate-Magnetic Seat? I need THAT Seat.

    OUR Secret ... won't tell anyone else. Promise.

  • Comment on Clinton McClung's answer…
    27434_1054177919_2296_n_small

    To SIFF Staff, AND these Askers:

    I have to say, am thrilled by the tone, tenor of these comments. Brave, articulate, AND NOT ranting OR defensive.

    PATHWAYS seems a Genius step to introduce NEW folks to the Range, available thru SIFF, that will result in toe-dipping, which leads to MORE wide-opening eyes.

    I, ACCIDENTALLY walked in to a theatre, I discovered by turning a corner on a do-nothing Spring evening, for what I simply thot was a double feature thingee. NOT realizing, til I walked out after, I'd just been to a Film Festival. The NEXT year, I saw 103 films. For the NEXT 20 years.

    Again, good goin', ALL involved, here.

  • Comment on Steve Schonberger's answer…
    Small_small

    This story rocks!

  • Comment on Steve Schonberger's answer…
    Img_0779_small

    That is totally awesome!