I'm not a fan of the average bar Hot Toddy with bourbon and honey, but I am a major devotee of the Irish Whiskey Skin. Hot Irish whiskey is the joint. Never mind the weird name.
2 oz Irish whiskey (preferably Redbreast; if you're feeling less flush, Bushmill's, Power's, or Jameson is fine)
1 tsp sugar/1 sugarcube
2 to 4 oz of hot water
a piece of lemon peel
If you want to do an American whiskey Toddy, and you want to do it right, do this:
2 oz Bourbon
1 sugar cube you scrape against an unpeeled lemon to get some of the oil
2 to 4 oz hot water
a small bit of broken up cinnamon stick
a slice of lemon with a couple/few cloves stuck in it
Another great hot drink with a weird name is Sano Grog. Sounds strange, but is delicious. Two of these and your sore throat will be cured. And your insomnia.
1 oz Bourbon
1 oz Jamaican rum
1/2 oz Grand Marnier
1/2 tsp sugar
2 to 4 oz hot water
thin slice of lemon floated on top